Always private
DuckDuckGo never tracks your searches.
Learn More
You can hide this reminder in Search Settings
All regions
Argentina
Australia
Austria
Belgium (fr)
Belgium (nl)
Brazil
Bulgaria
Canada (en)
Canada (fr)
Catalonia
Chile
China
Colombia
Croatia
Czech Republic
Denmark
Estonia
Finland
France
Germany
Greece
Hong Kong
Hungary
Iceland
India (en)
Indonesia (en)
Ireland
Israel (en)
Italy
Japan
Korea
Latvia
Lithuania
Malaysia (en)
Mexico
Netherlands
New Zealand
Norway
Pakistan (en)
Peru
Philippines (en)
Poland
Portugal
Romania
Russia
Saudi Arabia
Singapore
Slovakia
Slovenia
South Africa
Spain (ca)
Spain (es)
Sweden
Switzerland (de)
Switzerland (fr)
Taiwan
Thailand (en)
Turkey
Ukraine
United Kingdom
US (English)
US (Spanish)
Vietnam (en)
Safe search: moderate
Strict
Moderate
Off
Any time
Any time
Past day
Past week
Past month
Past year
  1. experimental-history.com

    Peer review was a huge, expensive intervention. By one estimate, scientists collectively spend 15,000 years reviewing papers every year. It can take months or years for a paper to wind its way through the review system, which is a big chunk of time when people are trying to do things like cure cancer and stop climate change. And universities fork over millions for access to peer-reviewed ...
    • Comments - The rise and fall of peer review - Experimental History

      The rise and fall of peer review. Copy link. Facebook. Email. Notes. More. The rise and fall of peer review. Adam Mastroianni. Dec 13, 2022. 1,054. ... is that peer review came out of those heady days of the early Cold War when THE EXPERTS arrived at the Pentagon. The most famous of these was MacNamara. I leave the Vietnam analogy in your ...

  2. wattsupwiththat.com

    Jan 2, 2023The Rise and Fall of Peer Review. 2 years ago. Charles Rotter. Adam Mastroianni has written a marvelous article at his substack, Experimental History, evaluating the history, the function and the misfunction of the peer review process. For the last 60 years or so, science has been running an experiment on itself. The experimental design wasn ...
  3. Peer review has been around for quite some time. But its history features interactions with the technology and forms of sharing information, with censorship, the rise and fall of generalists as well as concerns about marketing.
  4. econtalk.org

    Feb 13, 2023The peer review system has difficulty with highly innovative, interdisciplinary, and "out of the box" ideas because of the difficulty of identifying peers who can effectively evaluate such ideas. ... "The rise and fall of peer review," by Adam Mastroianni. Substack, Experimental History. Additional ideas and people mentioned in this podcast ...
  5. realclearscience.com

    The Rise and Fall of Peer Review . Adam Mastroianni Experimental History December 18, 2022 Anne Karakash from Pixabay For the last 60 years or so, science has been running an experiment on itself. The experimental design wasn't great; there was no randomization and no control group.
  6. 3quarksdaily.com

    Apr 13, 2023They called it "peer review." This was a massive change. From antiquity to modernity, scientists wrote letters and circulated monographs, and the main barriers stopping them from communicating their findings were the cost of paper, postage, or a printing press, or on rare occasions, the cost of a visit from the Catholic Church.
  7. Peer review is work that needs to be supported outside simply "service" (ideally that category ought to be far more robust and meaningful, but it sadly isn't). And research needs to measured less quantitatively. Reply reply ... The rise and fall of peer review ...
  8. The rise and fall of peer review: Why the greatest scientific experiment in history failed, and why that's a great thing ... even if the peer review process itself is suspect. I also know the authors had to put some semblance of effort into collecting the data in a reasonable format to get it through the publishing process. No so with the ...
  9. experimental-history.com

    The rise and fall of peer review. Copy link. Facebook. Email. Notes. More. The rise and fall of peer review. Adam Mastroianni. Dec 13, 2022. 1,054. ... is that peer review came out of those heady days of the early Cold War when THE EXPERTS arrived at the Pentagon. The most famous of these was MacNamara. I leave the Vietnam analogy in your ...
  10. news.ycombinator.com

    The rise and fall of peer review (experimentalhistory.substack.com) 199 points by Vinnl on Dec 15, 2022 | hide ... rather than peer-review. If we did away with "peer review" today, journals would still have to operate the same way -- they'd still have many more submissions than they have room for, so a team of people (ideally, peers) would need ...
  11. Can’t find what you’re looking for?

    Help us improve DuckDuckGo searches with your feedback

Custom date rangeX